Harbeth p3esr vs ls3 5a. May 12, 2011 · I've done several demos of the various modern incarnations of the LS3/5a against the Harbeth P3ESR and not a single customer could find anything they did which could equal the Harbeths. 06^ (2007-1977) = 2300 . Tone, do you have any more comparisons between the new Stirling LS3/5A and the Harbeth P3ESR? I am considering both these speakers for a small second system paired with a Marantz (VAC) 8B. The Falcon's and the Graham's are just ridiculously over-priced. Regardless, I like both but would give my nod to the P3's long term. Flipping the cab back round into the LS3/5A aspect has given Spendor the opportunity to squeeze a slightly larger bass unit in, 150mm vs. My amp is croft micro 25RS and a Series 7. right! The original HL-P3 was designed by Harbeth's Alan Shaw to replace the venerable BBC LS3/5A location monitor, of which Harbeth had been a licensee. In dramatic contrast, my Falcon Gold Badge LS3/5a's and Harbeth P3ESR XDs present recordings in a perfectly domesticated manner: precisely articulated, fantastic to view, and conspicuously miniaturized. One guy said they prefer original! Thanks! kw6 11-12-2020 9:49am 44 responses Add your response A question for connoisseurs of English sound. I find it hard to recommend anything over that price. Use Hifi Shark to monitor pricing and global availability. มวยถูกคู่ ระหว่าง Harbeth P3ESR XD vs Rogers LS3/5A Clsssic ถ้าจะว่าไปแล้ว ลำโพงจากอังกฤษ ทั้งสองโมเดล เป็นมวยถูกคู่ หรือลำโพงคู่ปรับกัน ก็คงต้องบอกอย่างนั้นจริงๆ 🔴Rogers LS3/5A VS Harbeth P3esr XD HiFi House by Msound 3. . I should go to LA in november, but I´m thinking that couldn´t be possible. The Falcon is an LS3/5a - the rest should be termed LS3/5a 'type' irrespective of how they perform and sound. Jun 26, 2015 · My thoughts on the differences between LS3/5a and the P3's, I feel the mid-bass/bass end of the LS3/5a is the limiting factor, the P3's will play louder and have to my ears a better punch factor to them. Bare in mind the LS3/5A used a B110, so quite a lot more surface area which should bring more headroom etc. Nov 14, 2025 · About two years ago I picked up a pair of Spendor 4/5 speakers which is their current incarnation of the LS3/5a. 54K subscribers Subscribe 🔴Harbeth P3ESR XD vs Rogers LS3/5A Classic SE HiFi House by Msound 3. The new Harbeth P3ESR X2 (or whatever is called) is too. I recently acquired a pair of early Falcon LS3/5as, Serial Numbers 00126 A & B. Author Topic: Harbeth P3ESR XD vs. Click to expand quite a statement? “never come close to selling any”?? Jul 28, 2020 · With well-worn LS3/5as costing £500-£1200 and cult variants fetching £5k+, Falcon's fee for a brand new pair – better-built than the originals! – is arguably a bargain. Hi Any who have compare the Stirling Broadcast BBC LS3/5a V2 and the Harbeth P3ESR. Radio 3 ? Superb. Selon ce qu'on écoute (rock, funk) cela peut être un avantage. Harbeth P3ESR 174. 106. The m30 and hl5 became the idols of m 🔴Rogers LS3/5A VS Harbeth P3esr XD HiFi House by Msound 3. Aug 13, 2022 · This is another LS3/5a derivative but unlike the others is far more tolerant of postioning and is actually a true bookshelf speaker, ie. Alan W. Time value of Money. The LS3/5a was designed as a BBC monitor to be used in cramped recording vans: "the BBC specifically set out to design a speaker to achieve natural overall sound quality and good dynamic range for monitoring broadcasts in tightly confined spaces". Used Harbeth LS3/5A Bookshelf speakers for sale on + second hand hifi sites & shops. Jul 28, 2020 · With well-worn LS3/5as costing £500-£1200 and cult variants fetching £5k+, Falcon's fee for a brand new pair – better-built than the originals! – is arguably a bargain. They have all the vocal magic of the originals but with better bass, smoother treble and handle more power. You are welcome to listen to my LS3/5As if you get to Orange County, CA. I understand the Falcon LS3/5a is as close as possible to the original production specification, including the formula for the adhesive used on the B110, (MJ’s academic background includes chemistry and adhesives), and the Kingswood Warren version as close as possible to the prototype. they can really be used successfully on a bookshelf, although obviously stands will give better performance. Kef ls3/5a piano vs Harbeth ls3/5a Maybe soon I'll be able to hear the P3ESR XD vs. Alan Shaw n'a fait que copier L'avantage de la Harbeth est qu'elle encaisse mieux la puissance. Harbeth P3ESR - Visitor - Speaker Asylum Stirling Broadcast LS3/5a vs. 211. Shaw designed the original HL-P3 loudspeaker to replace the LS3/5A built upon the BBC’s license. a Stirling LS3/5A V2 in direct comparison on the same system. Graham LS3/5, which is better? (Read 4192 times) 0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. 英國Harbeth新的XD系列 創辦人 Alan Shaw 在研發時 購入了更精準的高價儀器 更詳細的儀測數據 讓Harbeth的聲音規格更進化 也因此以 [XD]-Extended Definition Harbeth P3ESR vs the new XD Has anyone compare the two as heard the old one and stores only have xd now. Which "LS3/5a" style to discover after Harbeth P3ESR XD ? Discussion in ' Audio Hardware ' started by P3ESRXD, Aug 16, 2022. I've had various LS3/5as, including Falcons, over the years and currently use Harbeth P3-ESRs. You should also read John Atkinson’s more complete compendium of specialized knowledge on this speaker here. Stirling Broadcast LS3/5a vs. Under two grand for a 'modern LS3/5a' design. ProAc DB1 vs. Let’s say you started, in a brief bout of insanity, thinking that your 1992 Rogers LS3/5a were in need of an upgrade, and you could get good deals on both a Stirling Broadcast LS3/5a V3 and a Harbeth P3ESR, but no chance of auditioning either. 51 Posted by Visitor on December 15, 2010 at 17:24:35 I am interested in either of these and notice that the Stirling has two sets of binding posts. 400 x 1. A generation of home users and studio professionals have relied on these Harbeth minis to fill even the smallest room with a full, warm, natural sound. (For the full history of this classic design, click here. USD 400 (in year 1977 value) is equivalent to USD 2300 (in year 2007 value) if the annual inflation rate is averaging around 6%. Only thing I can contribute is that Harbeth have been around a long time and Dudley Harwood worked with the BBC to help develop the LS3/5A, Stirling only came on the scene once Spendor, Rogers, Harbeth, KEF stopped making speakers for the BBC. 140 of the 3/5. Let's see if this helps me decide on the XD since I've never heard Harbeth's little ones. vs LS3/5A With a slightly larger footprint (deeper by about 1 cm), the P3ESR (SE) is more composed than the LS3/5A. Features a dark wood finish with a black speaker grill. I thought it would be good to have a pair of '3/5as 'in reserve' to listen to from time to time. These were originally designed for small recording studios and mobile recording trucks to monitor on-location live sound. Les Harbeth sont plus adaptées à cette acoustique claire de par leur côté introverti et plutôt descendant. Any number of reviews, from authoritative evaluations—my favorite is Dick Olsher’s in The Abso!ute Sound of December 2010—to current and cursory blurbs, specialized multilingual fora, endless I now own the more costly Chartwell (Graham) LS6's, which are a bit larger than the LS3/5A-derived P3ESR's. 3) Proac Tablette 10. Lets ask our resident LS3/5a expert if he actually MADE any money from all his many many many many pairs of LS3/5a speakers or not. One moment, please Please wait while your request is being verified Re: Harbeth p3esr 24 Oct 2018, 19:21 @Jérôme Le concept du Thin Wall s'applique aussi à la ls3/5a puisqu'il est issu des études BBC. They were designed to work at close range in a small space like mine. best jan The Harbeth P3ESR is so far ahead of the 3/5A in every respect (they handle more power, go much louder without distorting, have a much nicer midrange and the treble is in a totally different league - active speakers be damned!) they can barely be compared now and many LS3/5A's themselves will be way outside their spec now in any case. My 'sort-of conclusion' is the little Harbeths are Spoiler stand-down. The list price is about the same as what you'd pay for a Falcon Gold Badge 3/5a and I like them better. Still can't believe how good they are. Put em on stands with a good front end and you'll be amazed. The new 'ESRs arrive in the next week or so, and as a long-term P-3 user I know just how good they are. Jul 28, 2020 · I've heard the Harbeths and I have Chartwell LS3/5As and you can't go wrong with either. History here is rich and surprising and you can learn about it in the review of that speaker’s anniversary edition here. . And the subwoofer lets you dial in some really solid bass - more than you'll get from an 8" 2-way. com (A) on June 8, 2023 at 18:53:30 I love the big, open soundstage you get from a S3/5R2, P3ESR, LS3/5a, etc. Although it is indeed slightly different from the ls3/5a (even if you I currently have Harbeth SLH5+ as main speaker (for sale on ebay). Has anyone compared them to the KEF LS 50's? Other suggestions appreciated. 2) LS-50 when they're all sale for $899. A photo of the Striling Broadcast BBC LS3/5a V3 crossover side by side with I presume the V2: Harbeth P3ESR's crossover: And the response of the Kef B110: It looks like the original LS3/5a crossover design was just as complex as Harbeth's: Harbeth Acoustics P3 ESR or XD version VS Falcon Acoustics LS 3/5A or Q7 Gold Badge Posted by el34eh@yahoo. 38K subscribers Subscribed seeking advice on small monitors Harbeth P3esr v KEF LS50 or ? « on: 27 Mar 2013, 01:09 am » Hello, I am looking to upgrade my Mordaunt Short MS 10s - any advice out there? I listened to a pair of Harbeth P3esr's which I quite liked. TIA Which "LS3/5a" style to discover after Harbeth P3ESR XD ? Discussion in ' Audio Hardware ' started by P3ESRXD, Aug 16, 2022. No scoops here. I doubt Harbeth's P3ESR would make as effective a studio monitor as Falcon's LS3/5a, but to my ears, the P3ESR was easier to position, and more satisfying with a broader range of music. Every time I put the P3ESRs back in my system after listening to another speaker, I think: Damn! These things sound so . If I wanted something bigger, fuller and further away with a similar nature I'd use BC1s or ESLs. I have demo's various versions of LS3/5A, including vintage and never come close to selling any against the Harbeth P3ESR, Anniversary or now XD. What is main difference in sound. 5K subscribers Subscribe The LS3/5A is a little near-field monitor, I'd just set it up for real close late night listening and enjoy it for what it is and what it does best. In addition to being able to play Led Zeppelin II without distress, they sound even more accurate (with deeper bass) than the wee Harbeths, and allow one to hear even deeper into recordings. ) Rogers 3/5a 15 Ohm or Harbeth P3ESR Page 1 of 1 Page 1 of 1 Board index » General Audio Discussion » Speakers All times are UTC บุคลิก จุดเด่น จุดด้อย ลำโพงเล็ก และประชันลำโพงROGERS LS3/5A classic VS Harbeth P3ESRติดตาม Après comparatif hier soir P3ESR vs ROYD Sapphir sur le petit système dans notre pièce à vivre assez claire d'environ 50 m², le constat est sans appel. Is it actually bi-wired? There is nothing in any of the reviews regarding this. In fact, the most perfunctory of web searches will tell you that along with the BBC LS3/5a, the Klipsch Heresy is one the most hackneyed subjects in hifi history. Pair of Harbeth BBC LS3/5A professional monitor loudspeakers. It can play a little louder without straining. as known, the best speakers reproducing perfect vocals were Harbeth. Sans parler de leur rendement un peu faible de 84 db sous 6 ohm Make sure to hear both the Falcon LS3/5a and Harbeth P3ESR - a friend brought over his original version of the P3ESR which sounded very different from the Falcons. Jul 28, 2020 · With well-worn LS3/5as costing £500-£1200 and cult variants fetching £5k+, Falcon's fee for a brand new pair – better-built than the originals! – is arguably a bargain. xwtcp, lcpau, us5w1m, fw9r, 9wyua, jjhq, esrg9, 58kg6, aren, 6lpc,